Jeremiah Monell, the man accused of killing his estranged wife, appeared in Cumberland County Superior Court.
BRIDGETON -- The man accused of stabbing his estranged wife to death and then eluding police for more than two weeks will remain in Cumberland County Jail awaiting trial without bail, a judge ruled Tuesday.
Jeremiah Monell, 32, of Cedarville, allegedly killed 35-year-old Tara O'Shea-Watson on Dec. 18 in her Commercial Township home. According to the Cumberland County Prosecutor's Office, their 12-year-old son witnessed the stabbing.
Monell appeared in Cumberland County Superior Court Tuesday for a detention hearing before Judge Cristen D'Arrgio. Per bail reform, it was up to the judge to decide whether an offender is fit to be released while awaiting trial -- based off three guidelines stating whether the accused is a danger to the community, what the likelihood is of the accused not appearing for court and whether the accused could interfere with the legal process. On all three grounds, D'Arrigo ruled that Monell should remain in jail.
"This was a rather brutal homicide done in the presence of minors and, there in and of itself, shows a grave risk to the community," said Assistant Prosecutor Mike Ostrowski to the judge. "I think that the act speaks for itself and this was, as I stated, multiple lacerations and stab wounds into various parts of the body."
Monell was charged with murder, violating a restraining order and weapons offenses for the death of O'Shea-Watson. The two were married, but estranged, with two children together. According to Ostrowski, O'Shea-Watson had a restraining order against Monell since May 2016.
O'Shea-Watson was found dead in her residence on Raymond Drive in the Laurel Lake section of Commercial Township on Dec. 19. A recording of a 911 call indicates that her son ran to the neighbors for help and that Monell was at the residence earlier to help fix her brake line. Police responded to the scene and spoke with the son.
"There was an interview with a 12-year-old minor who indicated that that person actually witnessed his father stab his mother to death," Ostrowski said.
"That father being Monell?" D'Arrigo said.
"Yes, judge," Ostrowski said.
In addition to the statement from their son, authorities also have video of what appears to be Monell's truck leaving from Laurel Lake after O'Shea-Watson was killed.
Monell was charged on Dec. 19 with O'Shea-Watson's death on Dec. 19 and he remained on the run for two weeks. According to Ostrowski, Monell was camping out in a tent in the woods avoiding arrest. New Jersey State Police arrested him in a wooded area off the Black Horse Pike in Folsom, Atlantic County.
Do restraining orders work? Experts weigh in
Monell was previously indicted on charges of burglary and violating an order to stay away from O'Shea-Watson. According to Ostrowski, Monell burglarized her Raymond Drive residence in April and assaulted her -- leaving broken glass in her residence and injuring her neck and nose. A Cumberland County Grand Jury indicted Monell in August but O'Shea-Watson dropped the charges against Monell in November, weeks before she was killed.
According to Lindsey Seidel, his court appointed attorney, O'Shea-Watson would invite Monell over to her residence, despite the restraining order. D'Arrigo argued, however, that the restaining order still needs to be honored.
"Even if he's invited, it doesn't matter because the obligation that Monell has is not to the victim but to the court," D'Arrigo said. "The prosecution is indicating that his inability to comply with that order, even if, hypothetically, the victim invited him over, that only establishes that he is willing to obstruct a court order."
In addition to D'Arrigo ruling that Monell remain in jail, the judge also said that he is forbidden from coming into contact with his 12-year-old son, because the son is a witness and Monell may attempt to influence the case.
Don E. Woods may be reached at dwoods@njadvancemedia.com. Follow him on Twitter @donewoods1. Find NJ.com on Facebook.